PANEL 2
Evaluating policies to overcome direct approach problem in Gurney hawker center
1. Selected existing policy: Consumer Protection Act 1999
This policy is selected because it provides protection to consumers at Gurney hawker center. Direct sellers, beggars, and pirated CD vendors are prohibited from approaching consumers when they are having their meal. If this act is breached, these people can be subjected to penalties. This protection act enables the consumers at the Gurney hawker center to fully enjoy their meal and not interfered by people begging or selling items.
2. Suggested policies:
(a) Policy to declare Gurney Hawker Center as tourism spot
Before Gurney hawker center can be declared as tourism spot, we must ensure the cleanliness and cosiness of the surrounding environment. There must also be a police patrol booth at the compound of the Gurney hawker center to ensure that the direct approaching activites are stopped. These police patrols should also patrol the surroundings of the hawker center other than standing guard at their respective booths. Signboards that prohibit direct approaches activities should also be set up at eye-catching corners to ward off these people. This policy’s strength lies on the fact that the cleanliness of the hawker center is assured of but the negative impact will be that the high cost needed to maintain the hawker center.
2. Policy to forbid direct selling business
When there is demand, there is supply. So, in order to solve the direct approach problem from the root itself, we have to tackle the consumers in the hawker stall. We must set a penalty rule that states that whoever that is involve in the direct selling business whether it’s buying of the goods or selling, he or she will be penalized. Therefore, we stop the consumers from supporting the direct approaching business. The policy should discourage people from giving money to the beggars as this will encourage more begging activities. Beggars should be relocated into the public funded centers. This policy’s strength is that the number of beggars will decrease but the cost of these public fund centers will increase dramatically.
3. Intensive prevention policy
This policy emphasizes the intensive way of preventing direct approaches be it direct sellers, beggars, or pirated CD sellers. We suggested a method which is to give out posters and stickers to the hawker operators around Gurney hawker center, so that they can stick at strategic places to inform the public. Telephone numbers of police stations, or law enforcing bodies should be stated in the poster. Therefore, we can encourage the public to be aware of this problem and call up when they observe direct selling activities in the hawker center. The good side about this policy is that we can encourage everybody from the hawker operators to the public to take part in solving this problem. The bad side is that it needs cost and time to carry out this policy as a lot of manpower is needed to campaign awareness among the public.